Is the PMI-PBA of more value than other BA certifications?

PMI-PBA

Is the PMI-PBA actually of more value than other Business Analysis certifications?


The PM & the BA – two different perspectives

In a ProjectTimes articleKiron Bondale described the oft-seen misalignment between Project Managers and Business Analysts.

In his article, he lists some comments made by each about the other…

From the Business Analyst’s point of view

From the business analysts, common complaints about project managers include:

  • Appear to be focused solely on cost or schedule constraints without also embracing the criticality of having good quality requirements
  • Demonstrate an unwillingness or inability to provide assistance in ensuring that stakeholders are attending and contributing to requirements gathering or review sessions
  • Don’t bother to read or understand high-level project requirements documents
  • Support or initiate scope change decisions without proactively engaging the business analyst

From the Project Manager’s side

On the other side, I’ve frequently met project managers who complain about business analysts who:

  • Appear to have no sense of time or cost constraints when producing their deliverables or appear unable or unwilling to provide effort or duration estimates for their work
  • Produce requirements documents which are unusable by other project team members or which don’t address the customer’s stated and unstated needs
  • Appear to forget that the second word in their job title actually implies the task of analyzing, distilling and refining requirements as opposed to just parroting what’s been received from stakeholders
  • Become unavailable for the remainder of the project’s lifetime as soon as their requirements documents have been signed off

 


The Passion of the Business Analyst

A lot of these comments are very familiar to me.

As a Business Analyst, I have often felt that the interests of the Project Manager weren’t always in the interest of the customer. More or less exactly what the comments above describe.

I have often felt that the interests of the Project Manager weren’t always in the interest of the customer.

Often the BA is the one that is talking with the various stakeholders from Management level through to the people performing the business tasks each day.

Because of this, the BA often feels that they understand what the real users want, as well as understanding their pain points.

As a professional, also, the BA wants to ensure that they have correctly, and thoroughly captured the users needs, and business/technical requirements, so that these are reflected in the final outcome.

This sometimes takes more effort than planned for, or expected. And this can cause
issues with the PM’s expectations who, while also wanting to provide a good solution, is also concerned with things such as costs, ongoing impact, etc.

PMI-PBA - Frustration of a Project Manager

 

Check this out:
Business Analysis Wisdom hard copy now available!

PMI-PBA Value

Does this “misalignment” occur because Project Managers are from Mars, and Business Analysts from Venus ? That because they come from different “worlds”, they have different views on reality?

Taking into account that the PM is the one “in charge” of the project, would it be that a BA with a better appreciation of the world/ideology/background of the PM is of more value to the project?

would it be that a BA with a better appreciation of the world/ideology/background of the PM is of more value to the project?

And … does this mean that the BA certification offering from the Project Manager Institute, is going to play a bigger part in projects in the future?

Your thoughts … ?


Want to learn more?

Below is a selection of resources that I personally feel are relevant to this blog post, and will allow you to get more in-depth knowledge. I do earn a commission if you purchase any of these, and for that I am grateful. Thank you. (Important Disclosure)

    1. Advait11%
    2. Advait11%

    Add Your Comment

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.